Sunday, February 3, 2019

How does the African Charter for Human and People’s Rights differ from other major human rights instruments?

ACHPR was one of the first instrument, instead of drafting separate documents, combined and included all together in one charter jus cogens, civil and political, social, economic and cultural rights and reaffirmed in the preamble that all human rights are interdependent and some (namely social, economic and cultural) rights cannot be treated as secondary rights.

Another notable difference, from other major universal human rights instruments or regionals, is the existence of separate chapter directed toward the duties of individuals with the regards to the rights of others, collective security, morality and the common interest. In the Charter, most interesting are duties toward the one’s “family and society, the State and other legally recognized communities.” ACHPR is the first human rights treaty which gave the considerable attention to individuals’ duties. The existence of mentioned chapter may be caused by the traditions and culture of African States, communities or peoples. But, also many of duties listed in Charter are standard obligations that any modern state places on its citizens. Same time, Charter receives most criticism to be more group-oriented, than toward the individual.

In contrast to other human rights instruments, ACHPR making very strong accent not only of the rights of an individual but on the “rights of peoples,” which can be explained from the perspective of historical circumstances. Historically, African people and African wealth were exploited and monopolized by the different foreign powers, therefore ACHPR stressed in several articles about the people's right to free themselves from colonization (Art. 20), dispose its own natural resources without deprivation (Art.21), national and international peace and security (Art. 23), “general satisfactory environment favorable to their development (Art. 24). Rights listed above, people's right or collective rights are called “third-generation” human rights.

In contrast to ICCPR or other international instruments, according to the African charter states are not permitted to derogate from the Articles of the Charter in situations of national emergencies

No comments:

Post a Comment

Are any human rights absolute?

There are certain human rights which can be said to be unchangeable in their nature. These ‘absolute’ rights cannot be suspended for any r...